Suffolk County district attorney Ray Tierney announced at a press conference last Thursday the identities of six unidentified cold case victims, with the oldest case dating to 1976.
Three of the identified people were homicide victims, found in Deer Park, Montauk, and Heckscher Park in the 1970s. While three others, whose deaths are either under investigation or more certain, were found in Riverhead, the Atlantic Ocean off Fire Island, and Montauk in the 1990s.
“Every person deserves to be known by their name, and every victim deserves answers and justice. Five decades have passed since the first of these individuals was found deceased, but our commitment to identifying them and pursuing justice has never wavered,” said Tierney. “Through advances in DNA technology, including Next Generation Sequencing, and the persistence of our Cold Case Task Force, we have been able to identify six individuals whose cases had long gone unsolved. Restoring their identities is about more than solving a cold case. It’s the first step in determining what happened to them and giving their families long-awaited answers that they deserve.”
The oldest case, nicknamed “Raymond Doe,” was identified as Ramon Perez Y Rivera, a native of Arecibo, Puerto Rico, who was discovered severely burned by a group of hunters in Deer Park in November 1976. Rivera was 41 years old, and last documented living in South Williamsburg, Brooklyn, in 1950. A gunshot wound to his lower right abdomen was ruled the cause of death.
The DA also announced the identity of “Montauk Mary” as Sofia Margherita Marrone of Pleasantville, N.J. Marrone was discovered near East Overlook Park in Montauk in March 1978, and died from four gunshot wounds. Marrone was 73 years old and last seen days before her death while leaving Shore Memorial Hospital in Somers Point, N.J.
Tierney said law enforcement has looked at Richard Biegenwald, a New Jersey serial killer convicted of six murders between 1958 and 1982, as a potential suspect. According to Tierney, Biegenwald picked up victims like Marrone walking in New Jersey towns. One witness told law enforcement they saw a bearded man sitting in a gold-colored car with New Jersey plates in the Montauk area, which matched a broad description of Biegenwald. The bullets used to kill Marrone, 22-caliber short rounds, were the same type Biegenwald used to kill his victims. Biegenwald died in 2008 while serving a life imprisonment term.
The third homicide victim identified was “Heckscher Jane Doe,” whose real name is Antoinette Rugg. On April 2, 1978, a leashed dog walking along the beach at Heckscher State Park scratched at loose sand, exposing the top of a human skull, according to the district attorney’s office. Law enforcement uncovered human skeletal remains with a tightly bound belt around the neck, determining the cause of death as strangulation.
Rugg was living in Lindenhurst and 26 years old when she died, leaving behind a 10-year-old son who attended the press conference announcing his mother’s identity publicly.
The DA’s office said these victims were identified using Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) and Investigative Genetic Genealogy (IGG), with the Cold Case Task Force developing “a traditional autosomal DNA profile from each victim’s remains and uploaded them to CODIS,” the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s DNA database.
The NGS technology, Tierney said, previously helped identify two Gilgo Beach murder victims, Karen Vergata and Valerie Mack, and helped them identify Rex Heuermann, who pleaded guilty to seven murders and is serving seven consecutive life sentences.
Three individuals found around Suffolk County in the 1990s were also identified.
“Riverhead Jane Doe,” found in March 1990, was identified as 32-year-old Kyong-Ok Kim of South Korea. Kim married and moved to Michigan in 1978, where she had a son. Around 1985, Kim became estranged from family, according to the DA, and moved to Woodside, Queens. Kim’s death is still under investigation according to the DA.
A “John Doe” was also identified as 28-year-old Omelios Steward, who was found floating in the Atlantic Ocean off Fire Island in November 1990 about nine miles south of Fire Island, and was believed to have drowned.
Another “John Doe” was identified as 27-year-old Andreas Kupke of Germany. Kupke was found on Dec. 24, 1999, along the high-tide mark east of Ditch Plains in Montauk and was scheduled to visit the United States from Nov. 24 to Dec. 4. After he failed to make his return flight from Newark International Airport, his parents in Germany reported their son missing to German authorities, the DA’s office said.
Anyone with information regarding these six individuals is encouraged to contact Suffolk Crime Stoppers at 1-800-220-TIPS, by visiting suffolkpd.org/Suffolk-Crimestoppers. Translation services are available.